Scarlett Faulkner Murder Trial: Were Threat Messages Just Keyboard Ranting?

Ashfak Juned
Nov 17, 2026 07:06 PM
Scarlett Faulkner, whose death is the subject of Central Criminal Court proceedings.

A 41-year-old woman standing trial for the murder of 28-year-old Scarlett Faulkner told gardaí during post-arrest interviews that messages sent to family members a day before the fatal assault were merely "ranting" and "keyboard warrior" remarks, as the Central Criminal Court in Ireland resumed playing recordings on Tuesday, 17 November 2026. Sitting before Mr Justice Kerida Naidoo and a jury of eight men and four women, the court heard that prosecuting counsel Seoirse Ó Dúnlaing SC has alleged the older accused acted in a joint enterprise with a 17-year-old co-accused and others to plan, organise, hunt down, intimidate, and harm Ms Faulkner, a mother-of-one from Longpavement in Limerick city, after she began a relationship with the accused's husband.

According to court coverage compiled by Daily Dazzling Dawn, jurors watched recordings of interviews conducted at Nenagh Garda Station in the days following the 21 March 2026 incident at Birdhill, Co Tipperary. Detective Garda Seamus Kelly told Mr Ó Dúnlaing that officers arrested the 41-year-old five days after the assault on suspicion of conspiracy to cause serious harm, while Ms Faulkner was in a coma at Cork University Hospital before her death on 13 April 2026 from a catastrophic brain injury.

Investigators put it to the accused during questioning that messages sent to Scarlett Faulkner's sister and to her husband's family preceded severe injuries by less than 24 hours. Daily Dazzling Dawn learned that the woman dismissed those messages as "just ranting" and "keyboard warrior stuff", adding that she did not have "as much as a piece of rope to do any harm". When officers asked how she could frame the messages as harmless given Ms Faulkner's critical condition, Daily Dazzling Dawn understands she replied that she felt sorry for the woman, adding, as told to journalists through the court record, "Please God she will be alright, I never went near the girl, she was knocked down by a car. It's on the internet. You need to investigate it properly."

Throughout the interviews, the accused maintained she had never laid a finger on Ms Faulkner and welcomed mobile phone footage circulating online, stating, as Daily Dazzling Dawn learned, "Thank God people did record it." Daily Dazzling Dawn understands she also asked officers, "If I went there to assault them how come I never went near either one of them", while questioning why she was arrested when only her husband had an axe at Birdhill. According to her account, her husband and Ms Faulkner exited a van first, her husband smashed the windows of her car with an axe, and others present ran down the road. She repeated claims that Ms Faulkner was struck by a silver car and "knocked out", urging gardaí to find a "hit and run driver", while arguing that any assault by the 17-year-old co-accused would not have caused serious injuries.

Gardaí put it to the 41-year-old that she and others, including the 17-year-old, broke into an apartment, assaulted a resident, used intimidation and violence to locate her husband and Ms Faulkner, chased her husband's vehicle for nine minutes, rammed it to force a stop before the co-accused attacked Ms Faulkner with an iron bar, and returned home for a "debrief". Daily Dazzling Dawn understands she rejected that summary outright, replying, "No, I wouldn't. Not a hope", and answering the debrief suggestion with, "That might be your take on it." She denied driving anger into the teenager, saying her husband smashed car windows and chased the co-accused, and stating the 17-year-old would not have exited the vehicle had her husband not "drove the windows in on top of them with a hatchet".

Asked why she was on that stretch of road at Birdhill, Daily Dazzling Dawn learned she said she wanted to recover her van and keys after reporting the van taken, denied ramming the vehicle, and claimed her husband swerved as she drove close beeping her horn. She also said she was hurt by her husband's betrayal, could never remarry because doing so is frowned upon in Traveller culture, and admitted smashing windows in a caravan her husband had bought for Ms Faulkner, asserting gardaí could not act against her for damaging her own property.

Earlier evidence before the jury included eyewitness accounts that Ms Faulkner was struck up to 11 times with an iron bar while lying on the ground, testimony describing rapid blows over music and calling the accused a "bull in a china shop", records of 267 phone calls on the accused's phone, forensic evidence that DNA matching Ms Faulkner was found on a blood-stained metal pole, medical evidence that she would not have recovered from her injuries, and references to earlier messages reading "I battered her with a bar" alongside her post-arrest claim, "I didn't lay a finger on that girl." The 41-year-old has pleaded not guilty to murder, not guilty to burglary, trespassing and criminal damage at an address in Co Tipperary on 20 March 2026, and not guilty to burglary and assault causing harm at an address in Limerick on 21 March 2026. The 17-year-old co-accused has pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to manslaughter, and the trial before Mr Justice Kerida Naidoo and the jury continues.

Full screen image
Scarlett Faulkner, whose death is the subject of Central Criminal Court proceedings.