Why Did It Take 37 Minutes to Dial 999 After Chloe Watson Was Stabbed?

Nahida Ashraf
Nov 19, 2026 04:39 PM
Sixteen-year-old Chloe Watson Dransfield from Gomersal died after being stabbed in Austhorpe in March 2026.

The prosecution has formally concluded its case at Leeds Crown Court in the murder trial of 16-year-old Chloe Watson Dransfield, moving proceedings into a pivotal phase as legal arguments take place behind closed doors today, Thursday, November 19, 2026. Chloe, from Gomersal, died after sustaining fatal stab wounds on Kennerleigh Avenue in Austhorpe during the early hours of Saturday, March 28, 2026. While 18-year-old Kayla Smith pleaded guilty to Chloe’s murder on the third day of the trial after initially admitting manslaughter, co-defendants Archie Rycroft, 20, of Middleton Park Road, and Chloe’s boyfriend, Blake Dowling, 18, deny murder and manslaughter, with their defence cases scheduled to commence tomorrow, Friday, November 20, before The Honourable Mr Justice Cavanagh.

Jurors were excused from attending Leeds Crown Court on Thursday as prosecution counsel Mark McKone KC and defence barristers, including Gill Batts KC and Mr Beharrylal, engaged in legal discussions following the formal closure of the Crown's case on Wednesday afternoon. Daily Dazzling Dawn understands that reporting restrictions apply to Thursday's private legal submissions, with the jury due to return at 10am on Friday to hear the opening of the defence cases. Throughout the past eight days of proceedings, the court has examined extensive forensic evidence, pathology findings, and agreed facts detailing the defendants' movements, police interviews, and digital footprints surrounding the fatal attack.

During the prosecution's case, forensic analyst Joshua Gladwin and forensic speech specialist Dr Catherine Earnshaw presented a detailed timeline reconstructed from CCTV footage, Ring doorbell recordings, cell-site location data, and mobile phone records. Journalists were told that tensions escalated between 2:51am and 3:45am on March 28 via phone calls and messages exchanged between Smith, who was at her grandfather’s summerhouse in Austhorpe, and Chloe, who was at Dowling’s residence. By 4:27am, Smith sent Chloe a threatening message reading, "Come catch this fade b**," to which the teenager replied, "ok sweet cheeks." Minutes later, at 4:37am, Smith messaged a friend stating she intended to stab Chloe, adding, "On my nana’s ashes," before repeating the threat at 4:53am. Around that time, Dowling booked a taxi to take himself and Chloe to Kennerleigh Avenue, with Chloe sending a photograph to a friend from inside the vehicle at 5:06am.

Enhanced Ring doorbell audio and CCTV footage captured the confrontation unfolding between 5:10am and 5:12am. Smith emerged from the garden summerhouse wearing pyjamas and carrying a knife, closely followed by Rycroft, who appeared to record the encounter on a mobile phone. Smith was heard shouting, "Come on, big girl" and "I will stab you," while Chloe repeatedly asked, "What, what, what, what, what." Prosecutors told the court Smith inflicted five stab wounds to Chloe's neck and back. During the two-minute incident, enhanced audio recorded a male voice saying "Chill," Dowling laughing, and another male voice stating, "Oh you stabbed her." As Smith and Rycroft retreated toward the summerhouse, Rycroft was heard saying, "I know… She wasn’t joking… stabbed her straight up," while Dowling shouted, "You’ve killed her, on ma’s life you’ve killed her," noting Chloe was on the ground foaming at the mouth. When Smith’s grandfather, Geoffrey Smith, stated he was calling the police, Kayla Smith allegedly replied, "You can’t ring the police, she’s dead."

Court records revealed that the first 999 call was not placed until 5:48am, marking an unexplained 37-minute delay following the stabbing. A second emergency call at 5:51am reported that Chloe had stopped breathing, prompting Geoffrey Smith to attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation with the help of a neighbour and a passing dog walker before police officers arrived between 6:15am and 6:22am. Chloe was pronounced dead at hospital at 6:40am. Meanwhile, mobile data and CCTV tracked Dowling leaving the scene at 5:55am with two males, travelling by taxi through a McDonald’s drive-through before arriving at a residence at 6:11am, where footage showed an unidentified item passed to Dowling and an exchange of his puffer jacket.

Agreed facts read to the jury established that Chloe's mobile phone was never recovered, though prosecutors presented evidence of a Snapchat video call on March 29 in which Dowling allegedly discussed trying to unlock Chloe’s bloodstained phone and burning his clothing. Investigators also recovered a snapped iPhone from a pond in Middleton whose SIM tray IMEI matched Dowling’s calls. Dowling subsequently handed himself in at Elland Road Police Station on March 30, answering "no comment" during his interview alongside an appropriate adult. Rycroft, whose toxicology tests indicated recent cocaine and nitrous oxide use, provided a prepared statement claiming he followed Smith out of curiosity, saw her swing her arm as if hitting someone without seeing a weapon, and assumed no injury occurred because Dowling was laughing.

The harrowing courtroom revelations have sparked widespread grief and debate across West Yorkshire, with members of the public questioning the choices made during the early hours of March 28. Reflecting the sentiment shared across community discussions, one local resident noted that had Chloe not entered that taxi, the tragedy might have been avoided, questioning why her boyfriend booked the vehicle and accompanied her to Austhorpe despite the explicit threats. Commentators also expressed deep concern over why Geoffrey Smith delayed dialling 999 and initiating first aid, noting that immediate wound pressure alongside CPR is critical when someone stops breathing. Many parents have echoed calls to teach young people self-respect and warn them that no relationship is worth physical confrontation, urging families to remain vigilant about where teenagers are and who they are with.

Full screen image
Sixteen-year-old Chloe Watson Dransfield from Gomersal died after being stabbed in Austhorpe in March 2026.