.svg)
In the shadowed corners of Europe’s most celebrated cathedrals and the ancient libraries of its universities lies a history that has been systematically obscured for centuries. As the continent grapples with modern questions of identity and migration, a groundbreaking new historical investigation is challenging the narrative that Islam is an outsider to the West. The release of Muslim Europe: A Journey in Search of a Fourteen Hundred Year History by travel writer and cultural critic Tharik Hussain offers a provocative thesis: Muslim civilization did not just exist on the fringes of Europe; it was a primary architect of its greatness.
The popular historical narrative often frames the Islamic presence in Europe solely through the lens of conflict or as a temporary occupation in Spain and the Balkans. However, emerging data and historical analysis suggest a far more symbiotic relationship. During the early 1990s Bosnian War, Enes Karic, the minister of education in Bosnia, frequently faced Western delegations who questioned the presence of a Muslim population in Europe. His response was always a reminder of shared roots, noting that Islam, like Christianity and Judaism, is a faith of the same Abrahamic lineage that has called Europe home for over a millennium.
Hussain’s work, which serves as both a travelogue and a historical excavation, argues that the "Clash of Civilizations" theory ignores the centuries of cross-pollination that birthed the European Renaissance. The evidence is etched into the very stone of the continent. From the ribbed vaults of Gothic churches that mirror the mosques of North Africa to the distinct Mudejar influences in the Baroque design of Cádiz Cathedral, the architectural DNA of Europe is inextricably linked to Islamic innovation. In Palermo, Sicily, churches sit upon the floor plans of former mosques, oriented towards Mecca, standing as silent witnesses to a time when Islamic rulers presided over one of the most culturally vibrant societies in Mediterranean history.
The disparity in development between Islamic Europe and its northern neighbors during the Middle Ages offers compelling statistical evidence of this influence. While London and Paris were struggling with basic sanitation and literacy in the 10th century, the Caliphate of Córdoba in southern Spain was a beacon of high civilization. Historical records indicate that Córdoba boasted paved streets, street lighting, and a library housing hundreds of thousands of volumes at a time when the largest libraries in Christian Europe held only a few hundred manuscripts.
This intellectual disparity fueled a massive transfer of knowledge that would eventually pull Europe out of the Dark Ages. The contributions were most profound in the sciences. While medieval English medicine relied on superstition, physicians in Al-Andalus were performing complex surgeries. Pioneering figures like Al-Zahrawi developed surgical instruments that remain in use today, and procedures for cataract removal and caesarean sections were documented with scientific rigor. These advancements were not isolated; they were transferred to the rest of the continent through translation movements in cities like Toledo, where Arabic texts on mathematics, astronomy, and philosophy were converted into Latin, providing the intellectual fuel for the European Renaissance.
Hussain’s journey documents these traces across the continent, moving beyond the well-known heritage of Spain to the overlooked Islamic history of the Balkans and the Mediterranean islands. In Cyprus, Sicily, and Malta, the layers of history reveal a complex interplay of faiths. The narrative brings to light the human stories behind the history, such as the synthesis of cultures found in the dervish lodges of Cyprus or the scholarly lineage of Tunisian imams in Sicily. It challenges the modern European Muslim to find "place identity"—a sense of belonging rooted in the soil of Europe not as a guest, but as a descendant of one of its founding civilizations.
This historical reframing is vital for the millions of Muslims currently living in the West. For the children of immigrants in Madrid, London, or Berlin, understanding that their heritage includes the architects of the Alhambra or the scientists of Córdoba offers a powerful counter-narrative to marginalization. It suggests that an Indonesian or Arab Muslim has as much historical claim to the cultural legacy of Andalusia as they do to their ancestral homelands.
The implications of this history extend beyond the Muslim community to all Europeans. Acknowledging the Islamic thread in the European tapestry does not diminish Western achievements but enriches them, revealing a civilization built on collaboration rather than isolation. Tharik Hussain’s work serves as a crucial reminder that the "Greatness" of Europe was never a monolithic achievement, but a collective triumph where Islamic ingenuity played an indispensable role. As Europe looks toward its future, the silent stones of Córdoba and the enduring texts of its medieval libraries offer a roadmap for how different faiths can once again build a golden age together.
